Einsteins Jewish Science Epub ´ Einsteins Jewish PDF

Einsteins Jewish Science Epub ´ Einsteins Jewish PDF

Einsteins Jewish Science [Ebook] ➧ Einsteins Jewish Science By Steven Gimbel – Capitalsoftworks.co.uk Is relativity Jewish The Nazis denigrated Albert Einstein’s revolutionary theory by calling it Jewish science a charge typical of the ideological excesses of Hitler and his followers Philosopher of Is relativity Jewish The Nazis denigrated Albert Einstein’s revolutionary theory by calling it Jewish science a charge typical of the ideological excesses of Hitler and his followers Philosopher of science Einsteins Jewish PDF or Steven Gimbel explores the many meanings of this provocative phrase and considers whether there is any sense in which Einstein’s theory of relativity is JewishArguing that we must take seriously the possibility that the Nazis were in some measure correct Gimbel examines Einstein and his work to explore how beliefs background and environment may—or may not—have influenced the work of the scientist You cannot understand Einstein’s science Gimbel declares without knowing the history religion and philosophy that influenced itNo one especially Einstein himself denies Einstein's Jewish heritage but many are uncomfortable saying that he was being a Jew while he was at his desk working To understand what Jewish means for Einstein’s work Gimbel first explores the many definitions of Jewish and asks whether there are elements of Talmudic thinking apparent in Einstein’s theory of relativity He applies this line of inuiry to other scientists including Isaac Newton RenĂ© Descartes Sigmund Freud and Émile Durkheim to consider whether their specific religious beliefs or backgrounds manifested in their scientific endeavors Einstein's Jewish Science intertwines science history philosophy theology and politics in fresh and fascinating ways to solve the multifaceted riddle of what religion means—and what it means to science There are some senses Gimbel claims in which Jews can find a special connection to E mc and this claim leads to the engaging spirited debate at the heart of this book.


10 thoughts on “Einsteins Jewish Science

  1. Mich Mich says:

    The book examines why the Nazis labelled his work as Jewish science examines to what extent the Jewish Talmudic way of thinking may have influenced Einstein's approach to theory of relativity and recounts the virulent anti semitism towards Einstein and other Jewish scientists The author is the chair of the dept of philosophy at Gettysberg College so there is some heavy philosophy in parts of this which can be skimmed and also some moderate scientific analysis of relativity In dealing with the Jewish way of thinking the author illustrates the Jewish contextual approach to solving problems For example the commandment Thou shall not steal is examined by the Talmud If one finds money can one keep it or is that stealing? The answer is based on the point of view of the person who lost it If it was found in the street most likely the person gave up hope of ever regaining it but if it was found in the person's home or with ID then one can't keep it The use of two boys together studying the Talmud to ensure that no one only has his point of view but is enriched by having two discussants is another example This is somewhat tenuous but no uestion there is a Jewish way of exploring ideas that deals with relative points of view Jewish style reasoning is where there is an absolute truth a metaphysical truth God's truth which is beyond our ability to grasp but elements of which are uncovered by seemingly contrasting human interpretationsThis is the connection to Einstein If one passes a magnet inside a coil of wire one generates an electric field If one passes the coil over the wire one also generates an electric force The theory of relativity is clearly a way of examining forces from different points of view However there was no Jewish content to Einstein's workThe Germans extolled nature Siegfried big blond hero and insisted that only from observations of nature could one develop science Einstein on the other hand manipulated mathematical symbols to derive his theories He was a modernist He was a Jew an internationalist and not a pure German The jealousy of other German scientists grew as Einstein's prominence increased and as they did not achieve various academic appointments which they sought German Nobel prize physicists Lenard and Stark engaged in virulent anti semitic attacks on Einstein and other Jewish scientists The author does a wonderful job of illustrating the painful pressures that caused Jewish scientists intellectuals and musicians to fleeThe author concludes with So is Einstein's theory of relativity Jewish science? Yes and no And that is precisely what makes it Jewish


  2. Dr. Awkward Dr. Awkward says:

    This book is enjoyable humorous and interesting Having said that it also gives off a strong vibe of being written for the sake of writing a book and the argument being slightly fabricated I also wish that the penultimate chapter which presented evidence that anti Einstein ism remains in our culture did to actually discuss the merits or lack of the anti Einstein aspect rather than simply making note of itDespite those complaints this was a fun and engaging read providing both entertainment a lot of wry and understated humor here and education bringing many pieces of history and science together for the sake of the narrative Rarely have I encountered a solidly academic book which was yet so easy to readIf you have interest in Einstein science the history of naturalism or Judaism it's worth a read


  3. Hadassah Brenner Hadassah Brenner says:

    Einstein’s Jewish Science was certainly thought provoking and provided an extensive explanation of the Nazi’s definition of Jewish science and the social history and context behind the term The book combines both philosophy physics sociology and a history of the world during the war era I did however find myself wondering how many texts were omitted or selected exclusively to support the author’s claims and by the end of the book though I may have learned much about Einstein and the reasons that his theory was discredited or disrespected I am still unsure as to what “Jewish Science” really means and if is legitimate to claim that such a notion exists I suppose that must have been Gimbel’s ultimate intention


  4. Uri Uri says:

    This is excellent for anyone who wants to know about science and its philosophy


  5. Zach Zach says:

    Every so often a book scratches an itch I didn't know I had This book revolves around the uestion Is Einstein's theory of relativity inherently Jewish? I initially thought the uestion reads as racist and the book follows the uestion with an exploration of the Nazi ideology and why German nationalists tried to discredit Einstein's theory through claims of faith More interestingly it traces the theories of Newton Copernicus and Descartes and examines the theological influences present in each I knew that our environment affects our perception but science to me has always been this monolith of observations leading toward facts full stop In fact that view of science alone is indicative of Western beliefs of an authoritarian God; as a counter example Chinese astronomy with its cyclical vision of time focused upon irregularities ellipses and comets versus the Western yearning to define the movement of the planets as clockworkAnyways the book is a series of logical investigations tying together the history of the Catholic church Jewish beliefs the development of relativity the German nation state's self perception and public opinion's focus upon Einstein I love when ideas dovetail because no knowledge exists in a vacuum and this book is entirely an exploration of those complicated relationships


  6. Joe Joe says:

    Tis is a book that is geared up to fight a windmill whose days are long past It gives a good review of old philosophy and incidents of the ugly German abnormal World influence now past I did not put it down as I am an History student and it did have some practices with which I was not familiar It is short read but the authors style seems to be impaired by his anxiousness to get his outrage on paper He of course is correct in his dellivery of events with respect to the Nazii'sAll and all it is not a read unless you wish to get the author's view of some historical events Their is no real dicussion of physics in the text


  7. Fred Kohn Fred Kohn says:

    I had to take away one star from this brilliant book because I didn't find it very well organized The author argues that it is not completely possible to separate a scientific method from a religious context This does not mean that it is fair to call Einstein's method Jewish science; in most ways it is not However the discussion of the Christian method of science which assumes access to absolute truth via a privileged reference frame a pope or the priesthood of an individual believer vs the Jewish method which assumes access to absolute truth via a consortium of non privileged frames the rabbinic method is fascinating


  8. Donna Donna says:

    This was not an easy read but it was a thoroughly thought provoking book Of the chapters Chapter three was the most compelling for me The scientific information challenged me I had to recall my meager scientific knowledge But the upside was melding my Jewish insights I applaud the author for taking on this subject and dealing with it in a balanced way Not a book for everyone but certainly one for those who want to explore how our beliefs affect our approach to science This book is relevant to our times


  9. Sharon Sharon says:

    I like the premise of this book at time I found it a bit heavy on the physicsphilosophy side which I guess is to be expected considering the subject matter Some times I felt like I had to push through the reading Finally I did not find the synthesis and conclusion that elucidating Still have a soft spot for Albert though


  10. David Berkowitz David Berkowitz says:

    It's often a fascinating read about Einstein with the perspective that his worldview was influenced by Judaism in ways similar to how Descartes was a Catholic scientist and Newton a Protestant scientist Yet the meandering narrative tried to cover too much ground with too many detours; often I was wondering when Einstein would return


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

10 thoughts on “Einsteins Jewish Science

  1. Mich Mich says:

    The book examines why the Nazis labelled his work as Jewish science examines to what extent the Jewish Talmudic way of thinking may have influenced Einstein's approach to theory of relativity and recounts the virulent anti semitism towards Einstein and other Jewish scientists The author is the chair of the dept of philosophy at Gettysberg College so there is some heavy philosophy in parts of this which can be skimmed and also some moderate scientific analysis of relativity In dealing with the Jewish way of thinking the author illustrates the Jewish contextual approach to solving problems For example the commandment Thou shall not steal is examined by the Talmud If one finds money can one keep it or is that stealing? The answer is based on the point of view of the person who lost it If it was found in the street most likely the person gave up hope of ever regaining it but if it was found in the person's home or with ID then one can't keep it The use of two boys together studying the Talmud to ensure that no one only has his point of view but is enriched by having two discussants is another example This is somewhat tenuous but no uestion there is a Jewish way of exploring ideas that deals with relative points of view Jewish style reasoning is where there is an absolute truth a metaphysical truth God's truth which is beyond our ability to grasp but elements of which are uncovered by seemingly contrasting human interpretationsThis is the connection to Einstein If one passes a magnet inside a coil of wire one generates an electric field If one passes the coil over the wire one also generates an electric force The theory of relativity is clearly a way of examining forces from different points of view However there was no Jewish content to Einstein's workThe Germans extolled nature Siegfried big blond hero and insisted that only from observations of nature could one develop science Einstein on the other hand manipulated mathematical symbols to derive his theories He was a modernist He was a Jew an internationalist and not a pure German The jealousy of other German scientists grew as Einstein's prominence increased and as they did not achieve various academic appointments which they sought German Nobel prize physicists Lenard and Stark engaged in virulent anti semitic attacks on Einstein and other Jewish scientists The author does a wonderful job of illustrating the painful pressures that caused Jewish scientists intellectuals and musicians to fleeThe author concludes with So is Einstein's theory of relativity Jewish science? Yes and no And that is precisely what makes it Jewish

  2. Dr. Awkward Dr. Awkward says:

    This book is enjoyable humorous and interesting Having said that it also gives off a strong vibe of being written for the sake of writing a book and the argument being slightly fabricated I also wish that the penultimate chapter which presented evidence that anti Einstein ism remains in our culture did to actually discuss the merits or lack of the anti Einstein aspect rather than simply making note of itDespite those complaints this was a fun and engaging read providing both entertainment a lot of wry and understated humor here and education bringing many pieces of history and science together for the sake of the narrative Rarely have I encountered a solidly academic book which was yet so easy to readIf you have interest in Einstein science the history of naturalism or Judaism it's worth a read

  3. Hadassah Brenner Hadassah Brenner says:

    Einstein’s Jewish Science was certainly thought provoking and provided an extensive explanation of the Nazi’s definition of Jewish science and the social history and context behind the term The book combines both philosophy physics sociology and a history of the world during the war era I did however find myself wondering how many texts were omitted or selected exclusively to support the author’s claims and by the end of the book though I may have learned much about Einstein and the reasons that his theory was discredited or disrespected I am still unsure as to what “Jewish Science” really means and if is legitimate to claim that such a notion exists I suppose that must have been Gimbel’s ultimate intention

  4. Uri Uri says:

    This is excellent for anyone who wants to know about science and its philosophy

  5. Zach Zach says:

    Every so often a book scratches an itch I didn't know I had This book revolves around the uestion Is Einstein's theory of relativity inherently Jewish? I initially thought the uestion reads as racist and the book follows the uestion with an exploration of the Nazi ideology and why German nationalists tried to discredit Einstein's theory through claims of faith More interestingly it traces the theories of Newton Copernicus and Descartes and examines the theological influences present in each I knew that our environment affects our perception but science to me has always been this monolith of observations leading toward facts full stop In fact that view of science alone is indicative of Western beliefs of an authoritarian God; as a counter example Chinese astronomy with its cyclical vision of time focused upon irregularities ellipses and comets versus the Western yearning to define the movement of the planets as clockworkAnyways the book is a series of logical investigations tying together the history of the Catholic church Jewish beliefs the development of relativity the German nation state's self perception and public opinion's focus upon Einstein I love when ideas dovetail because no knowledge exists in a vacuum and this book is entirely an exploration of those complicated relationships

  6. Joe Joe says:

    Tis is a book that is geared up to fight a windmill whose days are long past It gives a good review of old philosophy and incidents of the ugly German abnormal World influence now past I did not put it down as I am an History student and it did have some practices with which I was not familiar It is short read but the authors style seems to be impaired by his anxiousness to get his outrage on paper He of course is correct in his dellivery of events with respect to the Nazii'sAll and all it is not a read unless you wish to get the author's view of some historical events Their is no real dicussion of physics in the text

  7. Fred Kohn Fred Kohn says:

    I had to take away one star from this brilliant book because I didn't find it very well organized The author argues that it is not completely possible to separate a scientific method from a religious context This does not mean that it is fair to call Einstein's method Jewish science; in most ways it is not However the discussion of the Christian method of science which assumes access to absolute truth via a privileged reference frame a pope or the priesthood of an individual believer vs the Jewish method which assumes access to absolute truth via a consortium of non privileged frames the rabbinic method is fascinating

  8. Donna Donna says:

    This was not an easy read but it was a thoroughly thought provoking book Of the chapters Chapter three was the most compelling for me The scientific information challenged me I had to recall my meager scientific knowledge But the upside was melding my Jewish insights I applaud the author for taking on this subject and dealing with it in a balanced way Not a book for everyone but certainly one for those who want to explore how our beliefs affect our approach to science This book is relevant to our times

  9. Sharon Sharon says:

    I like the premise of this book at time I found it a bit heavy on the physicsphilosophy side which I guess is to be expected considering the subject matter Some times I felt like I had to push through the reading Finally I did not find the synthesis and conclusion that elucidating Still have a soft spot for Albert though

  10. David Berkowitz David Berkowitz says:

    It's often a fascinating read about Einstein with the perspective that his worldview was influenced by Judaism in ways similar to how Descartes was a Catholic scientist and Newton a Protestant scientist Yet the meandering narrative tried to cover too much ground with too many detours; often I was wondering when Einstein would return

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *